The Weekly: The Link Between Housing Resiliency and Affordability
The concept of adaptive capacity reveals that a household's ability to respond matters as much as its exposure.
The concept of adaptive capacity reveals that a household's ability to respond matters as much as its exposure.
Insights & ideas on resilience straight to your inbox.
Were you forwarded this email? → Subscribe here
As insurance premiums rise nationwide, the households bearing the largest increases aren't necessarily the most vulnerable. The ones most at risk are the ones with the fewest options when things go wrong.
On paper, wealthy homeowners bear the heaviest insurance burden. Between 2018 and 2022, average annual premiums in high-wealth, high-risk ZIP codes increased by over 10%, or $204—nearly four times the increase in the most economically vulnerable communities.
But a new Brookings Institution analysis suggests that it's the wrong number to watch. The households absorbing the largest dollar increases are also the most able to respond: by fireproofing, relocating, or upgrading to better insurance coverage.
In communities where incomes and home values are lower, households that are absorbing smaller increases tend to have fewer options. When insurance gets too expensive, they go without. And going without insurance, in a time when disasters are getting more frequent and destructive, can widen the nation’s wealth gap.
Using Treasury Department data on homeowners’ insurance from 2018 to 2022—combined with FEMA's National Risk Index and Census Bureau data on income, home values, and race—Brookings researchers mapped which zip codes are bearing the heaviest burden from rising premiums and nonrenewal rates.
Their research centers on a concept called adaptive capacity, or the ability of a household or community to plan for and respond to the impacts of extreme weather.
Brookings sorted U.S. zip codes into four categories based on climate exposure and the resources households have to respond. Eight percent are low-risk and well-resourced. Eighteen percent are "adaptable"—high exposure, but with the financial capacity to respond. Another 18% are "vulnerable"—high exposure, low resources.
But the most policy-relevant finding is the largest group: the 54% of zip codes classified as simply "at risk." These households span a wide range of incomes and hazard exposures, but they are at risk of quietly going uninsured.
Insurance market instability is a function of a community’s adaptive capacity, its exposure to hazards, and underlying disparities in access to homeownership. Consider California: the communities throughout the state at greatest financial risk from the insurance market's retreat are often the same ones that have historically faced barriers to homeownership. Housing resiliency and housing affordability converge in the same zip codes, which means the policy response should as well.
The maps where adaptive capacity is lowest and where the consequences of going uninsured are highest largely overlap, pointing toward policies such as strengthening federal infrastructure programs like FEMA’s Building Resilient Infrastructure and Communities (BRIC), requiring parcel-level climate risk disclosure so households can make informed decisions, updating land use rules to reduce future hazard exposure, and building pricing mechanisms that link risk mitigation to insurance premiums.
Go deeper here.

Read more about insurance on The Epicenter here.
Read more about resilient public infrastructure and government solutions on The Epicenter here.
Read more about resilient real estate on The Epicenter here.
Read more about private investment on The Epicenter here.

100%
Between 2014 and 2024, 100% of the 100 worst power outages in the central U.S. were caused by extreme weather. Source: Union of Concerned Scientists
Have thoughts to share or want to add your voice to the conversation? Reach out!
The Epicenter helps decision makers understand climate risks and discover viable resilience solutions. The Epicenter is an affiliated publication of The Resiliency Company, a 501(c)3 nonprofit dedicated to inspiring and empowering humanity to adapt to the accelerating challenges of the next 100+ years.