Climate-Risk Intelligence May Be Serving Too Narrow a Market
The analytics have never been better. Opening access could unlock much more investment in resilience.
The analytics have never been better. Opening access could unlock much more investment in resilience.
The climate-risk intelligence industry has made major advances in modeling, analytics, and putting numbers on risk. Consultancy BCG estimates its size at $1 billion to $1.5 billion in 2024, with a growth rate of 25–30% a year.
But better risk assessment was never the end goal of this industry. The bigger promise is to change where capital flows, what gets built, and how well communities withstand a changing climate. Much of that potential hasn’t been realized yet. Why?
Because the industry is optimizing for the wrong market. Climate-risk intelligence providers with world-class analytics compete for a narrow pool of paying customers—mainly banks and institutional investors—to hit revenue goals. But a much larger opportunity is still untapped: enabling cities and communities to make effective resilience investments and implement risk-reducing actions. Who controls, funds, and accesses climate-risk intelligence matters to unlocking this opportunity.
A recent exchange between academics underlines the importance of access and control. In “The Profitable Market for Climate Risk-Washing,” Jean-François Mercure and Jesse Abrams raise concerns about conflicts of interest and “risk-washing” in commercial climate-risk assessment. “Risk-washing” is the practice of understating “true” climate risk to keep customers happy. They argue that for-profit climate-risk intelligence providers are likely to engage in “risk-washing” because their business models rely on selling data, rather than staying true to an objective standard of risk assessment.
Professor Jakob Thomä responds in “The Case Against Making Everything a Public Good.” He points to the innovation in climate-risk intelligence that commercial providers have delivered. He also asks who will pay to build, maintain, and improve sophisticated climate-risk intelligence tools if not the commercial providers that Mercure and Abrams accuse of “risk-washing.”
Both raise important questions. But I want to add one more: How can public and commercial providers be organized to unlock resilience value for the broader economy and society?
The scale of the global resilience challenge is daunting. The latest UN Adaptation Gap Report puts the total need of developing countries at some $305 billion annually by 2035—or $420 billion when inflation is taken into account. In the U.S. alone, the government demand for adaptation and resilience is around $285 billion, according to Tailwind Futures.
Though the need is enormous, this alone does not guarantee commercial demand. Markets grow when innovation, policy, and investment make it possible to meet needs in ways that are useful, affordable, and financially viable. When it comes to the climate-risk intelligence market, in many sectors and geographies these conditions aren’t being met.
This means climate-risk intelligence providers have strong incentives to serve the customers who already pay: primarily banks and institutional investors. While this is a sensible approach for any single firm, collectively it can produce a short-sighted market. Increasingly sophisticated analytics serve a narrow base of wealthy buyers, while the larger resilience economy this intelligence could enable goes undeveloped.
This narrow base, in turn, shapes where innovation happens. Climate-risk intelligence increasingly feeds proprietary products for established commercial markets, from climate-risk scores and indices to portfolio-level financial impact models. Tools for cities, public infrastructure, development finance, and other underserved markets lag behind, even though they have vast potential to generate both commercial returns and public value.
The demand is there. Environmental disclosure platform CDP found that U.S. cities cite improved education and public awareness of climate issues, reduced depletion of natural resources, and expanded green space among the top benefits of adaptation action. Tellingly, cities that identified these benefits ahead of time reported taking four times as many adaptation actions. A broader-based climate-risk analytics market could help with this identification process.
High-quality, openly available risk intelligence could tear down barriers to innovation. This kind of open-access layer could allow new decision tools, financial products, and technologies to be created, and at a lower cost because developers would not have to start every application from scratch.
It could also enable coordination. Today, climate risk is largely measured one institution at a time. But climate resilience cannot be built in silos. To be effective, it has to be developed across systems and places. For this to happen, different actors have to work from a shared understanding of risk. This is what an open-access layer can provide.
GPS (Global Positioning System) offers a useful precedent. The U.S. government developed and funded GPS for military use, and for years it deliberately degraded the civilian signal. In 2000, it switched that degradation off. Civilian accuracy improved dramatically, while the government kept funding the underlying infrastructure.
This unfettering of GPS helped whole industries flourish. Established businesses could innovate, and new ones compete, on top of the existing GPS capabilities, instead of having to build their own positioning systems. For the U.S. alone, GPS produced some $1.4 trillion in benefits between 1984 and 2017, most of it in the decade from 2007.
The lesson is that GPS became far more valuable once the open version was good enough to build on. The same could hold for climate-risk intelligence. An open-access layer could enable new applications and strengthen collaborations that benefit far more people than those directly paying for the underlying data and compute.
But there is a real tension here. Making more climate-risk capability public could undercut private providers’ business models, which are built on paid access. Providers can reasonably argue that the freer and more open this intelligence becomes, the less revenue they earn from proprietary products, and the less capital they can invest in further innovation.
Failing to make this shift, however, carries its own risk. Public access can exist in name while staying too weak, generic, or poorly maintained to support innovation and coordination. There’s no shortage of public climate maps, portals, and datasets. Much of it is still too coarse, or stripped of context to support real decisions.
So the question isn’t only whether climate-risk intelligence is open. It’s whether the open layer is useful enough to become reliable infrastructure, like GPS.
Decision-useful climate-risk intelligence is expensive to build and has to keep improving. Whether it’s customers or taxpayers, someone has to pay.
Blended finance offers one model. It pairs public or philanthropic capital with private investment to fund projects that commercial money wouldn’t fund alone. Here, public and philanthropic funders could pay for the basic building blocks of climate-risk intelligence whose wider value is hard to monetize. Then commercial interests could build bespoke analytics, applications, and APIs on top of this foundational layer. A portion of the revenues from these services could then go back into sustaining and improving the underlying capabilities.
Public and philanthropic capital could also help create demand—for example, by funding pilot projects that show the value of open-access intelligence or supporting frameworks that build climate-risk intelligence into planning and investment.
Some climate-risk intelligence capabilities create the most value when they are open-access and widely shared. Think of New York City’s heat vulnerability index, which is being used by the Mayor’s Office of Climate and Environmental Justice, city agencies, and civic tech groups to identify at-risk populations and pilot cooling interventions.
Others deliver targeted value to very specific users and can support commercial competition. Investment portfolio-level climate risk scores are one example of this.
Looking across the climate-risk intelligence market today, there is an argument for expanding the open-access boundary, and putting greater capabilities into the public domain. Justin Mankin, associate professor of geography at Dartmouth, co-authored a recent study “Unlocking the benefits of transparent and reusable science for climate-risk management”, and argues that “There is no zero-sum game between trustworthy, publicly available science and private-sector innovation.”
But what is needed is serious investment in open-access intelligence so that it can be truly useful to stakeholders, like proprietary intelligence is to high-paying private customers today.
This doesn’t mean making every climate-risk intelligence product free. Nor does it require public providers to always outperform commercial ones. It means choosing more carefully which parts of the intelligence stack (the data, models, and tools beneath end-user products) are treated as shared infrastructure.
Those are the parts whose wider use unlocks value that markets alone are unlikely to capture.
Ujala Qadir has 20 years of international experience in climate finance, adaptation, and sustainable development, working with governments and international organizations across Africa, Asia, and the Caribbean. She is Lead Consultant, Resilience at The Climate Risk Group Pty Ltd (XDI and Climate Valuation), a climate-risk intelligence group. Previously, as Director of Strategic Programmes at the Climate Bonds Initiative, Ujala led the development of the Climate Bonds Resilience Taxonomy, helping advance adaptation and resilience as investable opportunities.
Have thoughts to share on this piece, or want to add your voice to the conversation? Reach out!